Friday, December 5, 2025
Brock's Only Independent Student Newspaper
One of the only worker-managed newspapers in Canada

The Supreme Court Killed the TikTok Star: the impact of TikTok on the success of new musicians 

|
|

While the TikTok ban on Jan. 19 stayed in effect for less than 24 hours after Trump put a reprieve in place, the popular entertainment app is still in danger of being censored by the United States Supreme Court, and with it, potentially the voices of many up-and-coming musicians.  

Over the course of the last eight years, TikTok has become one of the world’s most popular social media apps, with its parent company ByteDance estimated to have a valuation of $100 billion to $200 billion. While the app started off as a combination of the Chinese app “Douyin” and the popular lip-synching platform “Musical.ly,” by 2018, TikTok had become the most downloaded app in the United States and has only grown its global popularity since. 

While the concept of uploading short-form videos poses no threat to the Western world, it is TikTok’s parent company, the Chinese-based corporation ByteDance, that has been a cause for concern for some American politicians.  

“TikTok’s collection of reams of sensitive data about 170 million Americans and their contacts makes it a powerful tool for espionage,” U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar wrote in a government brief, “and TikTok’s role as a key channel of communication makes it a potent weapon for covert influence operations.”  

Following a series of legal proceedings, a law passed by the United States Congress and upheld by the United States Supreme Court stated that unless ByteDance sold TikTok in a process known as “qualified divestiture,” the app would be removed from the app store and banned for all users in the United States on Jan. 19. While the app was never sold and the ban came into effect on the night of Jan. 18, American TikTok users were back to using the app as usual before dinnertime the next day.  

Still, unless ByteDance sells the company, or works out some kind of back-door deal with President Donald Trump, TikTok’s accessibility to the United States is still in peril.  

And if TikTok goes down, the livelihoods of many up-and-coming American musicians may potentially disappear with it.  

During its near-decade on the market, TikTok has created hundreds of overnight celebrities due to its unique style of short content consumption. One night, a relatively unknown creator could post a video of themselves on the app doing just about anything and the next morning, that video could have blown up, the TikTok algorithm showing the video to millions of people around the globe. The format of the short, easily digestible video allows viewers to connect with the creator, getting a taste of what they have to offer without being bogged down by long-winded videos that take forever to get to the point. 

Although this feature has now become more common across platforms like Instagram, Facebook and YouTube, when TikTok first began to gain traction, it was a fairly novel concept. While some people have complained that it promotes mindless scrolling and short attention spans, TikTok’s quick, snappy and informative videos have allowed various people of varying backgrounds to gain exposure on the global stage, changing their lives forever. 

This has been the case for many young musicians who are now living a dream they once thought was impossible. 

Take Peter McPoland, a 24-year-old American musician who started his journey on TikTok in 2020 making videos from his attic bedroom in his parents’ home in Texas.  

Prior to his internet success, McPoland had released a few songs, none of which had found much traction. But when he posted a comedic video of himself playing the accordion and singing “Savage” by Megan Thee Stallion, he quickly went from getting a few thousand views to having a viral video with over 300 thousand likes. From there, McPoland was able to release singles such as “Romeo and Juliet,” “Elouise” and “Prom Queen” with great success. 

Since his quick ascension to fame in 2020, McPoland has been signed by Columbia Records, released a highly successful record titled Piggy and opened for Twenty One Pilots on The Icy Tour and Imagine Dragons on the Loom World Tour.  

While McPoland had made YouTube videos showcasing his music prior to blowing up on TikTok, he clearly owes much of his success to the exposure the app gave him in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.  

Other musicians such as Gigi Perez also owe their stardom to the popular entertainment app. While Perez had been making videos of her music on TikTok for years before a clip of her hit track “Sailor Song” went viral online, it was that overnight success that allowed her to sign a deal with Island Records.  

McPoland and Perez are only two examples of the hundreds of people who have found success as musicians on TikTok. Their livelihood and continued success rely on their ability to grow their following through the app and without it, others like them will be unable to find the same widespread exposure they did.  

While the ban currently only affects the United States, the expulsion of their 330-million-person population from using the app will likely do damage to the success of other up-and-coming musicians around the world as well. This is not only due to what would be a marked lack of eyes on the videos but also because many of the big music labels these artists find success through are based in the U.S.  

It does just remain true that one of the best ways for a young musician to build a following in 2025 is through TikTok. It’s more than an app that people dance on, and a ban will have consequences on the music scene that those who just see it as a silly low-effort dancing app might not realize.  

More by this author

RELATED ARTICLES

A look at some of the upcoming shows at The Warehouse 

For the music lovers in the Niagara Region who are looking for something fun to do, here are some of the upcoming shows scheduled to take place at The Warehouse.

Annabelle Dinda’s “The Hand” blew up overnight, but the final production might be considered a flop 

After going viral, Annabelle Dinda has released her newest single, “The Hand,” to middling applause.

A sparkling sip of ‘70s sunshine: Supertramp’s “Breakfast in America” 

When Supertramp released Breakfast in America in 1979, they knew that they’d created something special, but few could have predicted the album’s enduring cultural presence. More than four decades later, Breakfast in America remains one of the greatest achievements of the late-’70s pop-rock, blending clever songwriting, pristine production and a distinctive tonal palette into a cohesive and joyful listening experience.  

Mumford & Sons gear up for the release of their new record, “Prizefighter” 

If Mumford & Sons’ upcoming studio album, Prizefighter, is anything like the records that precede it, you can expect it to be a fan favourite right from the beginning.  

Brock University’s music ensembles are gearing up for their annual winter performance showcase  

As we head toward the end of the fall semester, Brock’s Department of Music is gearing up for the performances of its various music ensembles. As an annual tradition, these performances showcase the hard work of students who have been practicing all semester long.

P: Returning to Swift’s magnum opus five years later  

2020 was a strange year. Public life halted, yet the world kept moving. Tours and festivals shut down, school traditions were scrapped and artists were suddenly given the chance to pivot. 

Artist spotlight: Del Water Gap 

Indie pop heads and casual listeners alike can find something to love in the music and artistry of Del Water Gap.

Mumford & Sons and Hozier explore “rubber band theory” in their newest collaboration 

Mumford & Sons and Hozier have produced a beautiful new track, treating their fans to a folk collaboration for the ages.