Saturday, October 11, 2025
Brock's Only Independent Student Newspaper
One of the only worker-managed newspapers in Canada

Toronto Blue Jays 2023 Season: A struggle at the plate

|
|

Blue Jays struggles at the plate, concern heading down the stretch

As the 2023 MLB season unfolds, the Toronto Blue Jays find themselves facing an alarming trend – the struggle to generate offense.  

Despite having a roster packed with talent and potential, the Jays have been unable to take full advantage of games against supposedly weaker opponents, as evidenced by their recent encounter with the Colorado Rockies. 

On a Saturday night in Denver, the Blue Jays started strong, racing to a commanding 5-0 lead after just two innings. It appeared that they were poised for an easy win against a Rockies team that has been languishing at the bottom of the NL standings. However, what transpired over the next few innings would leave Jays fans frustrated and concerned. 

Lefty starter Yusei Kikuchi took the mound for the Blue Jays but struggled through 4.2 innings, allowing the Rockies several opportunities to claw their way back into the game. Kikuchi’s performance was far from his best, as he surrendered six hits and six runs (two earned), walking four batters along the way. 

Errors in the field added to Toronto’s woes, with infielder Ernie Clement committing two costly errors that directly led to four unearned runs for the Rockies. It was a stark reminder of how much the team missed their injured All-Star shortstop, Bo Bichette. 

Even reliever Yimi Garcia, who is usually reliable, faltered when he entered the game with runners on base, walking the first batter he faced in the fifth inning. This walk loaded the bases, setting the stage for Brenton Doyle’s bases-clearing triple that gave the Rockies a 7-5 lead. Three walks, all with two outs, proved to be the undoing of the Jays’ comfortable lead. 

In the fourth inning, with the chance to break the game wide open, star slugger Vladimir Guerrero Jr. meekly grounded out into an inning-ending double play. Instead of seizing the opportunity to secure the win, the Blue Jays squandered it. 

The game’s outcome was emblematic of the Blue Jays’ season-long struggles at the plate. Despite the early offensive bright spots, such as Kevin Kiermaier’s 438-foot homer, the team couldn’t maintain their momentum. They issued six walks, unforced errors against an opponent on a five-game losing streak. 

While this one game might not have had a significant impact on their wild-card race, it showcased a recurring issue for the Blue Jays. Good teams don’t open up 5-0 leads on weaker opponents only to relinquish them. The Jays are in a position where they need to make up ground in the standings, and such performances are inexcusable. 

The defeat in Denver was a part of a wild night in the American League wild-card race, with all four contenders experiencing various degrees of craziness in their respective contests. The Yankees managed to hold on for a 5-4 win over the Astros, while the Mariners secured an 8-7 win over the Mets. The Twins scored three runs in the 10th inning to defeat the Rangers 9-7, allowing the Jays to remain 1.5 games behind Texas for the final wild-card spot. 

Despite the defensive lapses and struggles on the mound, the Blue Jays made a late push in the ninth inning. George Springer and Davis Schneider set the stage for a potential comeback, but Guerrero Jr.’s fly ball to shallow center couldn’t bring home the tying run. Ultimately, the Blue Jays fell short in their rally attempt, highlighting their inability to capitalize on scoring opportunities. 

As the 2023 season progresses, the Blue Jays must address their offensive struggles if they hope to make a playoff push. While they possess the talent to compete with the best, their inconsistency at the plate and lapses in key moments have held them back. With the wild-card race heating up, time is running out for the Blue Jays to find their offensive groove and capitalize on winnable games. 

More by this author

RELATED ARTICLES

Blue Jays clinch the American League East  

Hot off one of the most exciting seasons in recent memory, the Blue Jays were crowned the American League East champions for the first time in a decade.  

Previewing the Brock women’s basketball season  

After their opening exhibition game against UBC Okanagan, it’s safe to say that the 2025-26 Brock women's basketball team is looking like a force to be reckoned with. 

Canada’s men’s 4×100 relay takes silver at world championships  

Amidst a wild stretch of competition in Tokyo for the World Athletics Championships, Team Canada finished second, returning home with a silver medal. Canada’s quartet consisted of Aaron Brown, Jerome Blake, Brendon Rodney and Andre De Grasse, all of whom were ready to defend the crown that they captured at the 2024 Olympics in Paris.

Wilson leads Aces and claims fourth MVP  

A’ja Wilson was named the 2025 WNBA MVP, becoming the first player in league history to win the award four times. 

Imane Khelif challenges boxing ban at CAS  

Imane Khelif’s position in international boxing has become one of the most contested issues in sport. The Algerian boxer, who won gold at the 2024 Paris Olympics in the women’s 66 kg division, now finds herself at the centre of legal disputes, regulatory battles and global debate about gender eligibility in athletics.

Tradition and spirit carry Steel Blade night  

Downtown St. Catharines carried a different kind of energy on Friday night. The Meridian Centre, filled with 3,700 spectators, became more than an arena; it was a meeting ground for tradition and community. The Steel Blade Classic, now in its 26th year, is no longer just a hockey game. The game has become the heartbeat of Brock's Homecoming — a reminder that belonging can be felt as much in the stands as it can on the ice.

Blue Jays playoff push: Yesavage impressive in season debut  

With a new day comes another comeback for the Blue Jays. Former Toronto 2024 first-round pick Trey Yesavage was called up for Monday’s game against the Tampa Bay Rays in an anticipated start.

Previewing the Brock women’s volleyball season  

The Brock women's volleyball team is coming off another successful year, falling short of another OUA title after losing to the McMaster Marauders in the finals. The 2024-25 season was an important one for the Badgers, as many of the team's best players would be leaving the next year — not to mention that they were fighting for their fourth straight Quigly Cup win.