Tuesday, March 3, 2026
Brock's Only Independent Student Newspaper
One of the only worker-managed newspapers in Canada

Sorry to break it to you, but cats are better than dogs 

|
|

Upon reading the title of this article, I know what you’re inevitably thinking: another internet treatise demanding allegiance in the great “cats vs. dogs” war. But indulge me, because the light-footed, whiskered aristocrats of the pet world deserve some serious appreciation — especially since you may have read otherwise.  

The case for cats is nothing short of elegance, independence and zero guilt. Many may insist that dogs are superior because they rely on you — needing you for walks, play and the very meaning of their day — but isn’t this exactly the problem? Don’t get me wrong — I think dogs are adorable — but why would I prefer a furry roommate who treats me like a mandatory walk-toilet-food machine over my cats? 

Cats, on the other hand, bring a refined sort of companionship. Many cats are perfectly content to be alone for stretches of the day. These animals are solitary by nature, meaning that you can go to work, run errands, live your life and return home without worrying if your pet has suffered a meltdown in the meantime.  

No guilt, no constant demands and no leash required. That is freedom — for them and for you.  

Cats are low maintenance luxury. Thinking logistically, cats groom themselves. Dogs? Not as reliable. Any dog owner knows that their pet needs regular baths, brushing and walks, even when it’s raining or snowing. Cats? They get themselves together and mostly stay out of your hair.  

Also, have you ever had to deal with a litter box? Sure, it has its own nuisances. But a cat’s elimination routine is contained, predictable and indoor-friendly. Compared to the saga of cleaning up after your rain-hating chihuahua throwing tantrums because “you didn’t walk me at precisely 6:42 p.m.,” I call that a modern convenience.  

Plus, cats won’t bark at every passing leaf, whine for a car ride or slobber on your shoes. They’re quiet. They smell less — usually, because yes, exceptions exist — and don’t demand attention like a toddler with fur. So, for many people with busy lifestyles, cat ownership is just … simpler.  

Dog-favourable rhetoric often frames obedience and “playing fetch” as virtues. But think about it: perhaps cats don’t fetch balls because they’re not desperate for a pat on the head every five minutes. Maybe they’re just too dignified for such games.  

Pro-cat writers even point to brain studies, arguing that cats are smarter than they’re typically given credit for. Their minds may not be wired to fetch or sit on command — but they’re sharp, independent, curious and perfectly capable of forming complex relationships with humans on their terms, not yours. 

When a cat slow-blinks at you after a long day — a subtle victory of trust — you realize that it’s not about subservience. It’s about respect. A cat doesn’t beg for your affection; you have to earn it. 

Cats are purr-fect companions that are ideally suited for modern life. Let’s be honest: a lot of people these days don’t have the time or lifestyle to commit to dog ownership. Many of us are faced with busy work schedules, travel, small apartments or unpredictable routines — none of which fit well with the constant demands of a dog. 

Cats, however, quietly slip into the cracks. They don’t need yard access. They don’t need long walks or complicated training. They don’t demand constant attention or disrupt your schedule with bark-induced guilt trips. 

What they do offer is soft paws curled on your lap at 3 a.m. They offer the occasional playful pounce out of nowhere. A knowing stare. A warmth, a purr and a presence —without expectations or drama. Cats bring championship in a form that respects your life and theirs.  

So yes, I’m with cats on this one. While I do understand why people love dogs — the loyalty, energy and “ride-or-die” vibes — I don’t believe that they’re superior.  

If I’m casting a vote, I choose independence over obligation, quiet over commotion and elegance over slobber. I prefer a companion who isn’t needy, who doesn’t require concession, who doesn’t rearrange your life — but somehow makes it better just by existing. 

If a dog is that friend who follows you everywhere hoping for a pat, a cat is the friend who silently walks beside you, occasionally hopping into your lap when you need them. 

So, sorry to all the dogs out there, but the throne for the best pet is occupied. And cats? They honestly don’t care.  

More by this author

RELATED ARTICLES

Brocks’s handling of budgetary issues has been shameful   

Brock University’s administration has been nothing short of shameful in the way that they’ve handled budgetary issues amidst Premier Doug Ford’s underfunding. The actions of Brock’s administration have negatively affected the student experience and brought the merits of Brock University’s education into question. 

Pierre Poilievre staying on as Conservative leader is a gift to Mark Carney 

Pierre Poilievre is the reason why the Liberals will be in power for a while. On Jan. 31, Pierre Poilievre won his Conservative leadership review with an outstanding 87.4 per cent of the vote. Though this is a major victory for Poilievre, this is not the end of his worries.  

Ontario healthcare carries us through crisis while shouldering the weight of underfunding 

Approximately 70 per cent of all countries have access to universal healthcare, and I was always proud to tell my American friends that I lived in one of those places — proud that I never had to worry about going bankrupt after an emergency room visit. I feel that this reassurance is a privilege, and for a long time, I only saw the positives. 

Social media has an alt-right pipeline problem, and women are its newest target 

Trends that urge women to step into their “divine feminine energy,” consume their way into a “clean girl aesthetic” and blame small mistakes on the fact they are “just a girl” are not products of neutral shifts in our algorithms. The differing frames women have been forced into online indicate subtle dog whistles to alt-right ideologies, ultimately functioning to naturalize conservatism, traditional gender roles and regressive choice feminism. 

The loneliness epidemic: a Gen-Z moral crisis, or a product of intimacy without dependency? 

If you’ve ever scrolled through social media, sat through a family dinner or had to endure a ‘situationship,’ surely you have been exposed to the common diagnosis of modern dating as a moral failure. It’s always the same arguments: the newer generation is impatient, nobody wants to put in the work, everyone is incapable of commitment and they’re all addicted to novelty. 

The presentation of technology and its inevitability  

For the first two decades of the 21st century, technology advanced at breakneck speed. Its rapid development often left sacrificed accountability, with tech being allowed to interfere with institutions like democracy, personal rights, privacy and ownership. 

The NHL is homophobic and the use of “Heated Rivalry” in their promotion doesn’t change that 

Piggybacking off the popularity of Crave’s new hit hockey show, Heated Rivalry, doesn’t make the NHL any less homophobic

Brock University’s Concurrent Education program is exhausting its students before they get the chance to become educators 

The Concurrent Education program at Brock University is unnecessarily difficult and ridiculously expensive, causing future educators to experience complete burnout before they even have a chance to reach the classroom.